In this Storyteller special edition walkthrough, I share the solutions in the same order as the chapters and puzzles. I include the alternative outcomes, Jester Stamps, Devil Levels, and achievements so I can find each solution in one place.
Walkthrough: All Chapters, Answers and Puzzle Solutions
I have organized the visual solutions by chapter. For each puzzle, I explain the story outcome I am aiming for and place its matching screenshot immediately below. When a puzzle has multiple solutions, I show them separately.
Table of Contents:
Chapter 1: Adventure
I start with five Adventure puzzles, following the Hero, Dragon, Princess, and the path to the throne.
Hero
I arrange the story so the Hero takes the sword, defeats the Dragon, and earns his reward.

Rampage
I make the Dragon kill every man and abduct the Princess.

Rescue
I bring the Hero and the Princess together in marriage.

Avenger
I let the Princess avenge her father and claim the role of Queen.

Everafter
I finish with the Princess becoming Queen and marrying the person who saved her.

Chapter 2: Heartbreaks
I use these solutions to cover healing heartbreak, grief, rejection, and Edgar’s wish, including the alternative endings.
Mending
I heal a broken heart using either of the two endings shown below.
Solution 1: Without any deaths

Solution 2: After a death

Miracle
I give a heartbreaking story a happy ending, with a miracle or an afterlife outcome.
Solution 1: Miracle

Solution 2: Afterlife

Grief
I bring comfort to the spouses who survive their partners.

Rejection
I make sure every character rejects Edgar.

Genie
I grant Edgar a wish, but the outcome leaves him heartbroken.

Chapter 3: Murder
In Murder, I follow the outcomes involving jealousy, haunting, wine, and Edgar’s wish for love.
Envy
I set up a killing driven by jealousy.

Wrath
I turn Edgar into a ghost who haunts his wife.

Pride
I show Isobel trying to escape her sorrow through wine.

Lust
I fulfill Edgar’s wish for love. I can use either version, depending on whether he stays innocent or becomes a murderer.
Solution 1: And he remains innocent

Solution 2: But he becomes a murderer

Chapter 4: Usurpers
I work through the throne-related puzzles here, keeping the Baron and Knight alternatives separate.
Enemies
I arrange the events to produce four deaths.

Merit
I make the Queen get married.

Dethroned
I put everyone on the throne, then choose the ending where either the Baron or the Knight takes control.
Solution 1: The Baron prevails

Solution 2: The Knight takes over

Pretenders
I have the Queen reclaim her crown from the usurper, using the Baron or the Knight version.
Solution 1: From the Baron

Solution 2: From the Knight

Chapter 5: Tragedies
I follow the five Tragedies puzzles and include both versions of the Aging solution.
Dismay
I leave every character with a broken heart.

Conflict
I bring the wives back together, only for them to start fighting again.

Aging
I make two lonely people grow old together. The screenshots cover matching ages and different ages.
Solution 1: Same age

Solution 2: Age difference

Loyalty
I let the dog age and suffer heartbreak, but give it a happy death.

Passion
I make the lovers drink lethal poison.

Chapter 6: The Manor
I use these images for the Manor’s murders, the Duke and Genie, and the arrest outcomes.
Despise
I build the story around a double murder.

Relief
I arrange the outcome so the Duke thanks the Genie.

Case
I get the murderer arrested. The two images show a confession route and a fingerprints route.
Solution 1: Confession

Solution 2: Fingerprints

Innocent
I make the Duke the one who gets arrested.

Chapter 7: Grimm
I follow the Grimm stories involving the Witch, Boar, and Bernard, including the three Gruesome outcomes.
Feast
I give the Witch enough to eat until she is satisfied.

Substitute
I make the Witch realize that she has eaten the wrong thing.

Gruesome
I feed the Boar, choosing Hansel, the Witch, or Gretel as the outcome shown in the images.
Solution 1: Hansel

Solution 2: The Witch

Solution 3: Gretel

Stepmother
I arrange for Bernard to murder his own wife.

Chapter 8: Apparitions
I use the four Apparitions solutions for the ghost stories involving Isobel and Edgar.
Closure
I create a heartbroken ghost.

Accident
I make Isobel haunt herself.

Revenge
I have Edgar murder his own wife.

Revenant
I make Edgar’s former wife drive him to take his own life.

Chapter 9: Beauty
I work through the Mirror, curse, frog, and Isobel stories in Beauty.
Competitor
I get the Mirror to praise the Witch.

Savior
I break the curse, either with Snowy saving the Prince or with the Prince saving his wife.
Solution 1: Snowy saves the Prince

Solution 2: The Prince saves his wife

Gratitude
I create the story of an ungrateful maiden.

Forgiveness
I arrange for a frog to receive a wish.

Airborne
I have Isobel kill a frog.

Chapter 10: Justice
I cover the Justice puzzles in order and keep each alternative execution or usurper ending distinct.
Treason
I make the usurper die, either at the Queen’s hands or at the Knight’s.
Solution 1: By the hand of the Queen

Solution 2: By the Knight

Misfortune
I arrange for the Knight’s wish to end with his beheading.

Stockholm
I create an unexpected execution, using the Queen or the Baron version.
Solution 1: The Queen

Solution 2: The Baron

Pardon
I make sure the usurper receives forgiveness.

Suitor
I arrange a story that ends with the Queen’s death.

Chapter 11: Secrets
I follow the murder and arrest outcomes in Secrets, including both versions of Report.
Caught
I make sure the murderer is arrested.

Payback
I arrange for the Butler to be shot.

Report
I have the Duchess get the murderer arrested. One image uses a murder report; the other covers the Duke being away.
Solution 1: Murder report

Solution 2: But the Duke isn’t home

Impostor
I get the Duchess to have the Baron arrested.

Chapter 12: Genesis
I use these five Genesis solutions for Eve, Adam, God, and Friedrich.
Damnation
I leave Eve suffering for eternity.

Temptation
I make Eve turn down temptation.

Redemption
I create an outcome in which God is proud of everyone.

Repentance
I arrange for Eve to shout at Adam.

Vengeance
I have Friedrich take revenge.

Chapter 13: Monsters
I cover the werewolf, Dracula, monster-hunting, and Bernard stories here.
Werewolf
I make Bernard take his own life.

Dracula
I arrange for Jon to rescue his wife.

Hunters
I slay a monster, choosing between the werewolf and Dragon solutions.
Solution 1: Werewolf dies

Solution 2: Dragon dies

Scent
I make the dog attack Bernard.

Revelation
I reveal Bernard’s secret to the Duke.

Chapter 14: The King
I follow the King chapter’s betrayals, beheadings, punishments, and throne outcome.
Betrayal
I arrange a story in which two people are beheaded, with a dead-husband version and a King’s-revenge version.
Solution 1: Dead husband

Solution 2: The King’s revenge

Promotion
I make the Maid behead the Queen.

Misfortune II
I arrange for the Knight’s wish to result in his beheading.

Machiavelli
I leave the Baron ruling alone.

Promotion II
I make the Knight behead the Maid.

Incompetence
I have the Baron arrange punishment for the Hero.

Chapter 15: Frankenstein
I use the Frankenstein solutions for the Doctor, the monster, and the reanimated pet, with alternative endings where shown.
Abomination
I bring the Doctor’s dead wife back to life, then choose a happy ending or one that leaves him heartbroken.
Solution 1: And they live happily ever after

Solution 2: But he ends up heartbroken

Regret
I make the monster jump from a cliff.

Company
I give the heartbroken monster happiness, either with the Doctor or with someone else.
Solution 1: With the Doctor

Solution 2: With someone else

Sematary
I bring a pet back to life and have it take revenge.

Contrition
I make remorse lead to the Doctor’s murder.

Chapter 16: Drama
I complete the Drama puzzles featuring Hatey, Ugly, Dandy, the King, and the Godot endings.
Oedipus
I have Hatey murder his father and marry his mother.

Hamlet
I make Ugly take the throne away from his brother.

Cain
I arrange for God to punish Dandy’s brother.

Salome
I make the King’s own daughter behead him.

Godot
I leave Ugly and Hatey waiting forever, either together or after both leave and return.
Solution 1: Together

Solution 2: Both leave and return

Chapter 17: Pirates
I follow the treasure-related puzzles for the Queen, Pirate, Marco, and Davy.
Loot
I return the treasure to the Queen, taking it from either the Pirate or Marco.
Solution 1: From the Pirate

Solution 2: From Marco

Thieves
I have Marco reclaim his treasure.

Buried
I arrange for the Pirate to bury the Queen’s treasure.

Sketchy
I make Marco earn a medal through theft.

Undead
I help Davy find peace again.

Chapter 18: Novels I
I use these four Novels I outcomes for Lenora, the Queen, the Witch, and Eve.
Lost Beauty
I make the Genie help Lenora feel beautiful again.

Naval Warfare
I have the Queen recover her stolen treasure.

Villain Match
I make the Witch face the consequences of provoking Isobel.

Atheist Grudge
I arrange for the Devil to refuse to torment Eve.

Chapter 19: Novels II
I work through the four Novels II outcomes involving the Genie, Hatey, Witch, and Duke.
Generous Genie
I make the Genie bring happiness to both men.

Mad King
I have Hatey kill everyone.

Unexpected Rival
I grant the Witch her wish.

Loose End
I arrange for the Duke to shoot the Detective so he can avoid prison.

Chapter 20: Novels III
I follow the Novels III solutions for the monarchs, Detective, Witch, and Hansel.
Order Restored
I help the monarchs take back their crowns from the usurper.

Unfair Trial
I have the Detective recognize his mistake.

Vindictive Wife
I make the Witch punish her unfaithful husband with a curse.

Macabre Dinner
I arrange for Hansel to regret eating the frog.

Final Chapter: Novels IV
I finish the main chapters with these four Novels IV puzzles.
Regretful Creator
I make the Doctor push a monster off a cliff.

Beauty Contest
I arrange for every character to become the Mirror’s favorite.

Dumb Usurper
I have the Princess kill the usurper.

Love Revolution
I make the peasants kill the monarchs and fall in love.

Jester Stamps
For the Jester Stamps, I follow each named objective and its corresponding solution image.
Fright
I make the Dragon release the Princess.

Outrage
I have the husbands realize that they share the same wife.

Naughty
I make the Witch eat the Boar out of spite.

Sixth Sense
I arrange for Edgar to frighten himself.

Deceit
I break Ugly’s curse.

Red-Handed
I arrange for the Butler to be fired.

Fear
I have the Duchess drink a martini.

Fraudster
I make the Dragon get arrested.

Gluttony
I create an outcome involving indigestion.

Spooks
I arrange for the Genie to be haunted.

Disgrace
I make Marco lose his medal.

Batrachian Affair
I have two frogs kiss each other.

Fruiticide
I create the pierced-fruit outcome.

Gourmand
I make sure a frog gets fed.

Disappointment
I arrange for someone to beat the Hero to the punch.

Devil Levels
I use these twelve Devil Levels screenshots to reach each listed outcome.
Avenger
I feed the Dragon.

Grief
I make a married couple reject each other.

Passion
I arrange for one of the lovers to be haunted.

Innocent
I have the Butler get shot.

Forgiveness
I make the Witch destroy her own cauldron.

Redemption
I have Adam die twice.

Abomination
I make the Doctor take his own life.

Godot
I arrange an ending in which everyone dies.

Undead
I make Davy explode.

Loose End
I have the Duke shoot his own wife.

Vindictive Wife
I make Snowy watch her husband drown.

Last Straw
I have the Knight behead his Queen.

Achievements
I finish with the achievements, keeping the original notes about where or how to obtain them.
Fed Up
For Fed Up, I arrange for the Maid to murder the King.

I can do this in Novels IV – Love Revolution.
Large Pet
For Large Pet, I break the Devil’s heart.

I can do this in Adventure – Avenger with the Devil active.
Werther
For Werther, I follow the story associated with Wolfgang von Goethe.

I can do this in Murder – Pride.
Romeo and Juliet
For Romeo and Juliet, I recreate the story associated with William Shakespeare.
I can use the Tragedies – Passion solution, but Edgar must drink poison before Lenora, following the order in which Romeo and Juliet die.
Silence
For Silence, I make Zypce sad.
I set Music to Off in the settings. Zypce is the game’s composer, and this makes him sad.
Worth It
For Worth It, I play for longer than two hours.
I need to play for more than two hours.
I obtain the other achievements automatically when I reach 100% completion.
